Click Here If You’ve Suffered Health Issues Due To Water Contamination
NEVER Settle
For Less

Millions Recovered For Our Clients

At McCutcheon & Hamner, we do not practice assembly line law. Get the just compensation you deserve. Reach out to our Florence personal injury attorneys today.

Best Lawyers - Firm Logo

Table of Contents

What Our Clients Say


Stacey Holland

Tom is one of the best go getters alive... He knows what's going on with you, as a person and as the opposition. He will fight tooth and nail for YOU! He is very educated when it comes to protecting his clients.

Nya Ari

I am very happy with the end result this business provided me. Very friendly staff and a warm business environment and my case was handled in a very professional manner by Joel and his partner. Would definitely refer his services to anyone.

Florence Personal Injury Lawyers

Championing the Rights of the Injured in North Alabama Since 1988

Florence is the flagship of the Florence-Muscle Shoals metropolitan statistical area home to some 40,000 hard-working residents. It’s known for its deep musical roots and abundant outdoor pursuits. Unfortunately, like residents in any other city in the U.S., North Alabamians in this picturesque community along the Tennessee River are not immune to accidents due to someone else’s negligence. 

Sustaining personal injuries in any type of accident can be a devastating experience. Injuries from unpredicted and unwarranted accidents caused by another person’s negligence or wrongdoing can result in serious medical issues that require extensive medical treatments that put you out of work for long periods of time while your medical expenses skyrocket. 

In the most serious cases, accidents can leave you with catastrophic injuries leading to permanent disabilities that are life-changing not only for you but for your entire family. 

No one should be exposed to this type of situation, yet, through human error and even malice, North Alabamian residents suffer serious injuries in a variety of scenarios every day.

You don’t have to fight this alone. If you or a loved one suffered injuries in an accident, you may be overwhelmed with the realities of undergoing short-term or long-term medical care involving hospitalization, surgery, outpatient care, rehabilitation, and more. This can make handling the details of a personal injury claim at such a time even more daunting. 

You need a Florence personal injury attorney on your side who will treat you with dignity and respect. An experienced attorney who will take your case seriously and handle all the legal matters of your case. You need a lawyer who will go toe-to-toe with the insurance company to get you the maximum compensation you need and deserve. You can trust the attorneys at McCutcheon & Hamner to fight for the very best outcome in your Florence personal injury case.

Tell us Your Story

Need help with a personal injury claim? Contact us Online or by calling (256) 333-5000 to discuss the details of your case.

Why Choose Us?

You're More Than A Number.

Do I Need a Lawyer for My Personal Injury Claim?

Florence Personal Injury Attorneys McCutcheon and Hamner
When you hire a personal injury lawyer from McCutcheon & Hamner, you can rest assured that all legal aspects of your case are being handled by a professional and that we have your best interests at heart. We will build a strong case to help you get the financial recovery you and your family need and deserve. We will begin right away by taking actions such as the following: 

Investigate Your Accident

Your personal injury lawyer will thoroughly investigate your accident by reviewing the evidence in your case, including the accident report, medical records, photos from the accident scene, and eyewitness testimony. A thorough investigation provides the evidence we need to convince the insurance company—and, if needed, the jury—to fully compensate you for your damages.

Identify All Liable Parties

Accidents can be complex, especially if they result in catastrophic injuries or death. Your lawyer will review all the evidence in your case to identify all liable parties. For example, a government agency may be held liable for not properly maintaining the street if a road hazard causes you to lose control of your vehicle. Or, a trucking company may be liable for negligent hiring if an inexperienced truck driver crashes into your vehicle. In some cases, multiple parties may be at fault, from whom you may seek compensation for your losses. 

Value Your Claim

Some of the best initial advice we give injured victims is to not accept an offer from an insurance company without first talking with a personal injury lawyer. Insurance companies are notorious for offering fast settlements to settle claims. But these offers don’t fully compensate victims for all their accident-related damages. Insurance companies hope accident victims will accept their offers without obtaining legal representation. But in doing so, injured victims end up leaving money on the table—financial compensation they and their families need and deserve.  If you accept an offer from the insurance, you cannot go back and ask for more money if your injuries require more extensive treatment than you initially thought or you’re out of work longer than expected. Your personal injury lawyer will consult with you, your family, and your doctor to determine the full impact your injuries have had on your life and the life of your family—now and in the future. And we will determine a more accurate value for your claim. 

Damages Available in Personal Injury Cases

Damages are the losses you sustained as a result of your accident injuries. Damages are usually divided into one of two categories—economic and non-economic. Economic damages represent monetary losses for which you can show an actual value, such as:
  • Medical bills for surgeries, medical procedures, hospitalizations, medication, rehabilitation, etc. 
  • Future medical needs
  • Modifications to your home
  • Equipment for mobility
  • Property damage
In the event your accident-related injuries prevent you from working, you may be able to recover compensation for damages such as: 
  • Lost wages or income 
  • Loss of future income if you cannot return to work in the same capacity as before the accident
Non-economic damages represent non-monetary losses, often described as pain and suffering. These types of damages are more subjective and, as a result, more difficult to value. Depending on your injuries, you may be entitled to non-economic compensatory damages such as:
  • Physical pain and discomfort
  • Emotional distress 
  • Mental anguish and trauma
  • Disfigurement and scarring
  • Decrease in quality of life
  • Humiliation 
  • Disabilities and permanent impairments
In Alabama, a spouse may also recover compensation for loss of consortium if the injured person is unable to provide the same marital relationship to their partner as they did before the accident. Since non-economic damages are more difficult to calculate, we usually rely on one of two methods to come up with a value for your claim—the multiplier method or the per diem method.
  • The multiplier method multiplies economic damages by a number between 1.5 and 5. The more severe the injuries, the higher the multiplier number. 
  • The per diem method is a daily value based on a daily rate, such as the injured person’s income. 

Insurance Companies Calculate Damages Differently

McCutcheon and Hamner law firm front deskInsurance companies use computer programs to calculate damages in accident claims. There are several different types of claims software, but they all work essentially the same. The insurance adjuster inputs data about the accident and the injuries into the software, and the program spits out a value range. The adjuster usually makes an offer to the injured victim based on this range.   There are many flaws with these one-size-fits-all programs, which causes them to spit out numbers that sorely undervalue the actual damages injury victims suffer. These programs overlook details such as specialized medical treatments, ongoing care, modifications to the home, or the emotional impact the accident has on the accident victim and their family. Your personal injury lawyer will more accurately value your claim to improve your chances of recovering maximum compensation for all your damages.

Negotiate with the Insurance Company for a Fair Settlement

Negotiation skills are one of the biggest assets an experienced attorney can bring to an accident claim. Your personal injury attorney is comfortable going up against insurers. Your attorney will reject that initial lowball offer and present evidence to support a demand for more accurate compensation. The insurance company will likely make a counteroffer.   Your lawyer will negotiate with the insurance company until a fair settlement is reached. Some insurance companies simply refuse to play fair. In those circumstances, we may recommend that you file a personal injury lawsuit seeking full financial recovery for your damages. 

Represent You in Court

If you decide to move forward with a personal injury lawsuit, your lawyer will file your case in civil court before the deadline. Alabama’s statute of limitations for negligence-based personal injury lawsuits is two years from the date of the injury. If you miss this deadline, you will be unable to recover compensation through Alabama’s court system.   Most personal injury cases—roughly 95%—settle before they reach the courtroom. Insurance companies prefer to avoid going to court if possible because trials are time-consuming and expensive. And sometimes, filing a lawsuit is enough to prompt them into making a fair offer. Your lawyer will continue to negotiate with the insurance company for a fair settlement.   Should your personal injury case is one of the few to make it to the courtroom, your Florence personal injury lawyer will aggressively and professionally represent you in court and advocate on your behalf for full compensation. 

Our Law Office in Florence

Our flagship office in Florence, Alabama, is located at 2210 Helton Drive. In addition, we offer services to many surrounding communities in the Northern Alabama area, including: 

Muscle Shoals (35661), Tuscumbia (35674), Sheffield (35660), Killen (35645), Rogersville (35652), St. Florian (35634), Leighton (35646), and Lexington (35648).

Florence Personal Injury Attorneys McCutcheon and Hamner Law Firm

Millions Recovered For OUR Clients

The Florence personal injury lawyers at McCutcheon & Hamner have handled over 50,000 personal injury claims and have successfully recovered more than $100 million in settlements and verdicts on behalf of our clients. We have also obtained the largest car accident verdicts in several counties. Our accomplished legal team brings thorough knowledge of Alabama personal injury law to your case along with tough negotiation skills. 

Whether you have been injured in an auto accident or injured on the job, our knowledge will put your case at an advantage when dealing with responsible parties and their insurers. We also are in command of strong litigation skills if your personal injury lawsuit goes to trial. Most cases settle outside of court, but our Florence personal injury attorneys are ready to apply aggressive representation in court should the insurance company refuse to offer a just and fair and just settlement. Contact us today for a free and confidential consultation, and let us show you what your case is really worth. 

Automobile Accident
Automobile Accident
Automobile Accident
Automobile Accident
Automobile Accident
Jury Verdict

Elite Legal Representation

Put Our Decades of Experience to Work For You.

Thomas W. McCutcheon Jr.

Born in Jefferson County, Alabama, September 4, 1959 Admitted: 1988, Alabama, U.S. District Court, Northern District of …

View Profile +
Thomas McCutcheon

We Don't Want to Be Everyone's Lawyer - We Want to be YOUR Lawyer

Our Legal Services

At McCutcheon & Hamner, we prepare every case as if it will go to trial. Through thorough investigation and documented evidence, we put your case in the strongest possible position. Many personal injury lawyers fail to put in this effort. We have learned that through thorough preparation of all cases, we can obtain the most value for our clients in terms of compensation for medical expenses, pain and suffering, lost income, property damage, emotional trauma, and more.

We handle all North Alabama personal injury claims and lawsuits, including the following:

We also provide representation for Social Security Disability benefits as well as workers’ compensation. In all practice areas, our legal team and staff bring a deep sense of empathy to you as a client. We start by thoroughly familiarizing ourselves with the details of your case so that we can work towards recovering maximum compensation for you and your family.

Huntsville Bicycle Accident Attorney, Thomas W. McCutcheon Jr.

Contact a Florence Personal Injury Lawyer at McCutcheon & Hamner Today

Our attorneys are serious about justice from the beginning of each client relationship. We never let an injured or unrehearsed client be questioned by a trained insurance adjuster; doing so can damage your case from the start. We are here to provide you with the guidance and representation you need throughout all phases of your case. Let us take on the legal burden so that you can focus on your recovery and move forward with your life with peace of mind of knowing that your claim or lawsuit rests in the hands of a proven personal injury law firm.

Ready to get started? Call (256) 333-5000 to arrange for your free consultation today.

The Opinions That Matter Most

Our Clients Share Their Stories
He was nice, kept us informed, and wrapped our case up in a timely manner!
- S. Fortenbury
Saying they are professional and reliable attorneys is an understatement. They have gone above and beyond to help me, even when I was unreasonable and impatient.
- C.M.

Let Us Fight For You

Your Recovery is Our Priority

Our Firm's Latest News

Stay In The Know